Best Homemade
Ice Cream on Island

This popular ice cream shop on Sanibel’s east-end focuses on hand crafted products, unique presentations and the very best ingredients. Our loyal customers will always remember the quality and taste of our ice cream, which can truly be called home made. We strive to have the best quality, cleanliness and service so that our loyal fans will return for the best ice cream Sanibel has ever tasted.


Hear what they have to say about Us!

"Nice little shop and patisserie. Service was very quick and they were following all of the current health guidelines which was comforting to see. I had the dolphin tracks. It was very interesting and very good. Definitely got my money's worth. My wife had a build your own ice cream bowl and was pleased as well. Perfect little shop to stop at if you're looking for a frozen sweet treat."
via Google
"The beautiful junonia flavor ice cream was just heavenly! We went back the next day for another one before we had to head back home."
via Google
"This parlor is lovely! I can’t wait to go back— everything was clean and the service was fast and everyone working was friendly too. They are following all of the Covid guidelines. They have so many flavors to choose from it took me some time to choose what I wanted. Seriously, go!"
via Google
"Just so much fun! If you're looking for ice cream that is homemade, look no further! My family and I had all different flavors and everyone was unbelievable! Try Sea Shells, Sandpiper, and the Double Dark Chocolate! The VERY best!!"
via Google
"The shops name is so true. Best ice cream my family and I have had. The portions are amazing for a one scope. The owner gave us a little info about how they make it, which is cool of her. If you're able to stop do so."
Must Visit
via Google
"I started following Sanibel's Best on instagram and saw all of their delicious treats. After following them for a month or so, I decided to finally go and get a treat in person. Everything was just how I thought it would be... it was AMAZING!! Nothing short of a masterpiece from this tiny ice cream parlor. Keep up the great work :)"
via Google


Thank you to the island residents and supporters of Sanibel’s Best Homemade Ice Cream for their business. Please keep supporting us and all other local businesses. Call us at (239)476-0796 for delivery options, all of our treats are available for delivery! We can also run anything out to your car, drive-thru style. Thank you!

Scroll to top