Flavors

Homemade Ice Cream

  • Ding Dong the TROLL is Gone! – Pistachio Ice Cream with Chunky Peanut Butter.
  • Dolphin Tracks – We encourage the public to stay informed and consider becoming a member of Captains for Clean Water. Water quality affects everything from our economy to our way of life. Proceeds will be going towards Captains for Clean Water with every scoop of Dolphin Tracks sold in the year 2020. White cake-based flavor with chocolate chips rainbow sprinkles and marshmallows. 
  • The Sandpiper –  Caramel based ice cream with layers of caramel swirl, chocolate chips, and crushed whoppers
  • Sanibel Sea Shells – Butter pecan base ice cream with nuts, chocolate, and toasted coconut. 
  • The Beautiful Junonia – White cake based ice cream with an amaretto flavor and slices of toasted almonds
  • Nana and Pops Kisses – Chocolate Ice Cream with Chunky Peanut Butter.
  • Purple Cow – Black raspberry with chocolate chips
  • Shot In The Dark – Coffee-based ice cream with chocolate-covered espresso beans mixed with a sea-salted fudge swirl.
  • Pelican Poop – Vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and marshmallow fluff.
  • A Slice of Paradise (Birthday Cake)
  • Buttonwood Perfection (Butter Pecan)
  • Ally’s After Dinner Mint (Mint Chocolate Chip)
  • Sweet Hibiscus (Strawberry)
  • Island Time (Cherry Vanilla)
  • Wake Up Call (Mocha Java)
  • Stingray Fever (Caramel Praline Pecan)
  • Sea Urchin Special (Double Dark Chocolate)
  • Sanibel Snow (Vanilla)
  • Pumpkin Gingersnap (Fall flavor)
  • Barnacle Bits (Chocolate Chip)
  • Burrowing Sea Snail (Cookie Dough)
  • Spotted Octopus (Cookies & Cream)
  • Bunny Kraz (Butter Finger)
  • Ride’em Sea Horsie (Heath Bar)
  • Ally’s Lighter Delight (SF/FF Mint Chocolate Chip)
  • Snooze Button (SF/FF Mocha Java)
  • Skinny Coconuts (SF/FF Coconut)

Sorbet

  • Sanibel Sunshine (Mango Sorbet)
  • Pink Flamingo (Red Raspberry Lemon Sorbet)
  • Sanibel Sunset (Georgia Peach Sorbet)
  • Wild Starfish (Wild Cherry Sorbet)
  • Pucker Up (Lemon Sorbet)

Sherbet

  • Leafy Seadragon (Lime Sherbet)
  • Blown’ Bubbles (Watermelon Sherbet)

Gelato

  • Sanibel Sand Dunes (Dulce De Leche Gelato)
  • Nutty Woodpecker (Nocciola Gelato)
  • Pink Mermaid (Red Raspberry Gelato)

Frozen Yogurt

  • Key West Paradise (Keylime Frozen Yogurt)
  • 1 Flavor Kiddie Bowl/Cone
  • 1 Flavor Small Bowl
  • 1 or 2 Flavor Medium Bowl
  • 1,2, or 3 Flavor Large Bowl
  • Homemade Waffle Bowl
  • ICE CREAM CONES
  • Single Flavor Waffle Cone
  • Double Flavor Waffle Cone
  • Single Flavor Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Double Flavor Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Single Flavor Spinkle Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Double Flavor Spinkle Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Single Flavor Peanut Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Double Flavor Peanut Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • ALL OUR WAFFLE CONES ARE HOMEMADE
  • WITH A SECRET WAFFLE CONE RECIPE!
TOPPINGS:

Sauce: Hot Fudge • Chocolate • Strawberry • Pineapple • Caramel

Candy: M&M’s • Sprinkles • Heath Bar • Reese’s • Butterfingers • Oreos• Chocolate Chips • Gummi Bears • Gummi Worms

Nuts: Pecans • Toasted Coconuts • Mixed Nuts

SANIBEL’S BEST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM IS AVAILABLE IN PINT & QUART SIZES!

Scroll to top