Flavors

  • Ding Dong the TROLL is Gone! – Pistachio Ice Cream with Chunky Peanut Butter.
  • Dolphin Tracks – We encourage the public to stay informed and consider becoming a member for Captains for Clean Water. Water quality affects everything from our economy to our way of life. Proceeds will be going towards Captains for Clean Water with every scoop of Dolphin Tracks sold in the year of 2020. White cake-based flavor with chocolate chips rainbow sprinkles and marshmallows. 
  • The Sandpiper –  caramel based ice cream, crushed malt balls, chocolate chips with our secret recipe
  • Sanibel Sea Shells – Vanilla based ice cream with toasted coconut, mixed nuts enrobed in chocolate with our secret recipe!
  • The Beautiful Junonia – white cake based ice cream with an amaretto flavor and slices of toasted almonds
  • Nana and Pops Kisses – Chocolate Ice Cream with Chunky Peanut Butter.
  • Purple Cow – black raspberry with chocolate chips
  • Birthday Cake
  • Butter Pecan
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Strawberry
  • Cherry Vanilla
  • Parrot’s Nest
  • Toffee Coffee
  • Mocha Java
  • Caramel Praline Pecan
  • Double Dark Chocolate
  • Vanilla
  • Pumpkin Gingersnap (fall flavor)
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Cookie Dough
  • Cookies & Cream
  • Butter Finger
  • Heath Bar
  • SF/FF Mint Chocolate Chip
  • SF/FF Mocha Java
  • Mango Sorbet
  • Lemon Sherbet
  • Red Raspberry Lemon Sorbet
  • Georgia Peach Sorbet
  • Blueberry Sorbet
  • Wild Cherry Sorbet
  • Lime Sherbet
  • Watermelon Sherbet
  • Dulce De Leche Gelato
  • Nocciola Gelato
  • Red Raspberry Gelato
  • Zuppa Gelato
  • Keylime Frozen Yogurt
  • 1 Flavor Kiddie Bowl/Cone
  • 1 Flavor Small Bowl
  • 1 or 2 Flavor Medium Bowl
  • 1,2, or 3 Flavor Large Bowl
  • Homemade Waffle Bowl
  • ICE CREAM CONES
  • Single Flavor Waffle Cone
  • Double Flavor Waffle Cone
  • Single Flavor Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Double Flavor Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Single Flavor Spinkle Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Double Flavor Spinkle Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Single Flavor Peanut Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • Double Flavor Peanut Chocolate Dipped Cone
  • ALL OUR WAFFLE CONES ARE HOMEMADE
  • WITH A SECRET WAFFLE CONE RECIPE!
  • Key Lime Sublime Hurricane – Our Key Lime Frozen Yogurt Blended with Toasted Coconut & Pineapple Topping
  • Create Your Own Hurricane – Select Our Vanilla or Chocolate Premium Ice Cream with Your Favorite Topping

**All Sundaes are prepared with Whipped Cream & a Cherry

  • Beachwalk – Dirty Sandpiper Ice Cream, Chocolate Syrup, Crushed Whoppers, Dusted with Cocoa
  • Brownie Explosion – Vanilla Bean Ice Cream on top of Brownie Bites, Hot Fudge Sauce, Mixed Nuts
  • Chocolate Chocolate – Double Dark Chocolate Ice Cream, M&M’s & Lots of Sweet Chocolate Syrup
  • Mud Pie – Mocha Java Ice Cream, Chocolate Syrup, Crushed Oreos & Chopped Nuts
  • Sea Turtle – Vanilla bean ice Cream, Caramel Sauce, Chocolate Syrup & Roasted Pecans
  • Sanibel Sunset – Sanibel Seashells Ice Cream, Strawberry and Pineapple Toppings & Toasted Coconut
  • Tropical Temptation – Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, Banana,  Hot Fudge & Roasted Pecans
  • Create Your Own Sundae – Select 1 Flavor Ice Cream, 1 Topping or Sauce, 1 Candy or Nut Topping SPECIALTY
  • Sanibel’s Best Rainbow Cup – Mango, Lemon Sorbetto & Watermelon, Lime Sherbet
  • Sanibel’s Best Dirt Cup – Vanilla or Chocolate Sanibel’s Best Premium Ice Cream with crushed Oreos, Chocolate Syrup & Gummi Worms

THE UNBELIEVABLE SANIBEL’S “BEST” BANANA SPLIT!! 32oz

Up to 3 Sanibel’s Best Ice Cream Flavors (6 scoops), Banana, Chocolate & Caramel Sauce, Strawberry & Pineapple Sauce, Rainbow Sprinkles, Gummies, Oreos, Nuts, M&M’s, Whipped Cream & Cherries!

Specialty Items

SANIBEL’S BEST MILK SHAKES – 24 oz

SANIBEL’S BEST MALTS – 24 oz

SANIBEL’S BEST ICE CREAM FLOATS – 20 oz

SANIBEL’S BEST SMOOTHIES – 24 oz
Sanibel’s Best Premium Vanilla Ice Cream, Orange Juice & Your Choice of Banana, Black Raspberry, Mango, Kiwi, Strawberry or Strawberry Fruit Base with Whipped Cream

MR. JAYS – 24 oz
Mango Sorbet, Orange Juice, 1 Banana, Strawberry & Pineapple Fruit Base

SANIBEL’S BEST VERY, VERY, BERRY SMOOTHIE – 24 oz
Sanibel’s Best Purple Cow Ice Cream, Orange and Strawberry Fruit Base

Sanibel’s Best Café Captiva – Sanibel’s Best Premium Vanilla Ice Cream, Coffee or Expresso, Chocolate Syrup

PRETZEL BREAD or BRIOCHE BREAD – Hot off the Press… Pretzel or Brioche Panini stuffed with our Best premium Ice Cream or Gelato of your choice. Add chocolate or caramel sauce and dusted with confection powered sugar!  HOT ON THE OUTSIDE AND COLD ON THE INSIDE…WHAT A COMBO!

TOPPINGS:

Sauce: Hot Fudge • Chocolate • Strawberry • Pineapple • Caramel

Candy: M&M’s • Sprinkles • Heath Bar • Reese’s • Butterfingers • Oreos• Chocolate Chips • Gummi Bears • Gummi Worms

Nuts: Pecans • Toasted Coconuts • Mixed Nuts

SANIBEL’S BEST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM IS AVAILABLE IN PINT & QUART SIZES!

Scroll to top